by | Mar 6 2008

The New Jersey primary on Feb 5th, 2008 led to reports of serious problems with Sequoia voting machines. See below for our letter to NJ Attorney General Anne Milgram calling for a full investigation to address these problems.

Dear Attorney General Milgram:
Local newspapers recently reported that election administrators in Mercer, Union, Ocean, Bergen, Gloucester and Middlesex counties discovered that some of the Sequoia Advantage voting machines reported incorrect ballot counts in the February 5th presidential primary.


From these news accounts, we believe that this problem most probably indicates a serious software error, one that suggests the possibility of deeper problems that could significantly impact the integrity of elections run on Sequoia Advantage voting machines.  We urge the Attorney General’s office to treat this problem with the highest concern and suggest that the State immediately impound the troubled machines along with a sample of machines from the same jurisdictions that did not exhibit the problem.   We then ask that the State appoint an independent team of experts to examine the machines, their source code, and if necessary their binary code, for any errors that may explain the discrepancies.  


We stress the importance of retaining an independent and objective expert to evaluate these malfunctions, rather than relying on Sequoia Voting Systems, Inc., to examine and report on this problem.  Sequoia has pending sales contracts in excess of $20,000,000 with counties in New Jersey for printers to be retrofitted to these machines. This presents an inherent conflict of interest for Sequoia. The evaluation should be done by an unaffiliated party.  Other states have recently undertaken such examinations, most notably California, which led to the de-certification of many direct record electronic voting machines.

 

Having studied and investigated voting machine performance in great depth, we would be happy to offer the Attorney General’s office any assistance we may be able to provide in addressing this critical matter.

 

Thank you very much for your attention to this serious problem. We look forward to working with you.


Respectfully Yours,

 

 

Holly Jacobson

Director, VoterAction.org

 

VotersUnite.org

Dr. Andrew Appel, Princeton University

Irene Goldman, Director, New Jersey Coalition for Peace Action

Dr. David Jefferson, Lawrence Livermore Laboratories

Pamela Smith, President Verified Voting Foundation

Renee Steinhagen, Director, New Jersey Appleseed

Penny Venetis, Rutgers University Constitutional Law Clinic

Dr. Dan Wallach, Rice University

 

*Affiliations are listed for identification purposes only*

 

cc:

 
The Hon. Anne Milgram
Office of The Attorney General
Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex (HJC)
8th Floor, West Wing
25 Market Street
Trenton, NJ 08625-0080
 
The Hon. Jon S. Corzine 
Office of the Governor
PO Box 001
Trenton, NJ 08625
 
  
The Hon. Nina Mitchell Wells
Secretary of State
Office of the Secretary
PO Box 300
Trenton, NJ 08625-0300
 
SENT BY US MAIL AND BY FAX