Banfield v. Cortés
In August 2006, a group of Pennsylvania voters filed a lawsuit in Pennsylvania state court challenging the use of electronic voting machines on the grounds that it violated the state election code and the state constitution’s guarantee of the right to vote. The lawsuit, which named the Pennsylvania Secretary of State as a defendant, sought to halt the continued use of DRE voting systems in the state.
Status of Case
In April 2007, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania held that voters have a right under the Pennsylvania constitution to reliable and secure voting systems and may challenge the use of electronic voting machines “that provide no way for Electors to know whether their votes will be recognized” through voter verification or independent audit. The Pennsylvania Secretary of State has filed a petition before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court seeking to appeal this ruling. That petition, which has stayed any proceedings toward trial before the lower court, remains pending before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.
The Philadelphia law firm of Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP, the Public Interest Law Center of Philadelphia, and Chester County attorney Marian K. Schneider serve as counsel for the plaintiffs in this case. The lawsuit was filed with the support of Voter Action.





